The Rev. Dr. Endicott Peabody
The Rev. William Greenough Thayer
The Rev. Charles Lewis Slattery
The Rev. Edward Henry Newbegin
The Rev. Thomas Legate Fisher
The Rev. Dr. Endicott Peabody
The Rev. Thomas Legate Fisher
The Rev. Arthur Lewis Bumpus
The Rev. Williston Merrick Ford
The Rev. Angus Dun
The Rev. Leslie Frederick Wallace
The Rev. Richard Taylor Lyford (Interim Vicar)
The Rev. John Russell Dallinger
The Rev. Laird Wingate Snell
The Rev. Edward Joseph Day
The Rev. Dr. Hugh Latimer Willson
The Rev. John Crocker
The Rev. Dr. William Henry Paine Hatch
The Rev. Henry Mattocks
The Rev. Henry Mattocks
The Rev. Donn Russell Brown
The Rev. Paul Sprower Koumrian
The Rev. William Dudley Underhill (Interim Rector)
The Rev. Martha Hughlett Giltinan
The Rev. Alan Bruce MacKillop (Interim Rector)
The Rev. Joseph Scott Baker
The Rev. Dr. Edward Charles Kienzle (Interim Rector)
The Rev. Alan Bruce MacKillop (Priest in Residence)
The Rev. Joyce Lynn Scherer-Hoock

1889-1892
1892-1894
1894-1896
1896-1899
1900-1901
1901-1940
1901-1910
1910-1913
1913-1917
1917-1919
1919-1924
1924-1925
1925-1926
1926-1934
1934-1938
1939-1947
1940-1950
1947-1948
1948-1950
1950-1968
1968-1975
1976-1989
1989-1991
1991-2001
2001-2002
2002-2005
2005
2005-2009
2009-